Skip to content

The Journal · Market structure

The agencies moved. The statute did not.

American regulators are building pathways for onchain markets without waiting for Congress. Pathways are not a market-structure settlement.

Through 2026 the US Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission stopped behaving like two institutions waiting to be told whose problem crypto was. Task forces, joint interpretations, a March memorandum of understanding, a harmonisation initiative, staff FAQs and formal proposals have given firms something they did not have: a map, incomplete, of how to ask.

A list of nine moves is easy to misread as a finish line. It is not. Agencies can reduce uncertainty. Only Congress can write the durable settlement. The CLARITY Act is not over because the agencies got to work.

Chapter 01 · 1 of 4

Guidance, proposals, and law are different clocks

Agencies can open a path. Only a statute can close the argument.

The SEC’s August 2026 proposal, Regulation Crypto Assets, and its October custody proposal are formal rulemaking. They are not yet final rules. Other steps — task forces, Project Crypto, joint interpretations, the innovation-relief ideas, the CFTC’s innovation task force and its crypto FAQs — are coordination, guidance or policy. A firm that treats all nine as the same kind of object will build on sand.

The distinction is the whole story. An examiner can use a FAQ on Monday and a court can ignore it on Tuesday. A proposed rule can still change. A statute, if it comes, is what survives a change of chair.

Chapter 02 · 2 of 4

The new fact is a shared operating model

The most important development is not any single press release. It is the two agencies acting as if they might supervise one market. The March memorandum set up joint work on policy, examinations, enforcement, product definitions, clearing, collateral, dual registration and reporting.

That matters because the American problem was never a pure absence of rules. It was that a serious firm could not get a stable answer to basic questions. Is this a security, a commodity, a payment instrument, or something that does not fit? Which regulator is in charge? May a broker, an exchange, a fund or a bank custody it, list it, clear it, finance it? Which customer-protection, capital, disclosure and reporting rules apply? Can tokenised collateral and stablecoin settlement sit inside a firm that already has a licence?

Chapter 03 · 3 of 4

Build for the question that is still open

The current push is aimed at those bottlenecks, not at a victory lap. A harmonisation initiative that works on collateral, clearing and dual registration is more useful to an institution than a speech about innovation. The CFTC’s FAQ work on tokenised permitted investments, tokenised collateral and blockchain recordkeeping is the sort of text an operations team can actually implement.

Innovation relief, where it is still only under consideration, would be a temporary legal path for specific onchain activity. Temporary is not an insult. It is a description. Products designed as if the exemption were the end state will be redesigned.

Chapter 04 · 4 of 4

A posture for builders

Label every input before you depend on it: final rule, proposal, staff FAQ, memorandum, enforcement action. Design the product around the questions a dual-registered firm still cannot answer cleanly. Do not tell a board that Congress has finished.

The direction of travel is real. US supervisors are no longer passive. The settlement of American market structure is not. Both sentences can be true, and a serious firm needs both.

All field notes

Illustrative commercial design only. This is not legal, tax, investment, employment or securities advice, and it is not an offer to the public, a solicitation to invest, or a promise of funding, equity or returns. Structures vary by venture and must be drafted for the incorporation jurisdiction by qualified startup, tax and securities counsel. Blockchain Lab does not claim to be a licensed investment manager, broker or bank on the basis of this website.